Self(ish)

Struggling with depression again as I have been a bit lately, I’ve come to finally accept something about myself: I really don’t possess the selflessness necessary for this being-a-mother thing.

Depression has magnified this lack, I think. Or perhaps I’m just more aware of it, as I’m more myopic and sensitive to all of my shortcomings and failings — as a friend, partner, writer, boss, human being, all of it, all of it. And it’s a form of self-centeredness in itself, the daily accounting of what I lack, how I have fallen short, how I have disappointed. All of this, the countless facets of my deficiency, are thrown into stark relief most when I deal with my daughter because she above all other people on this planet earth requires and requests so much of me on a daily basis. The things she wants, the energy she needs, her questions that require answers, the endless barrage of busywork and errands related to taking care of another, much-less-able human being, is just so, so exhausting. And by “exhausting” I don’t even mean tiring or physically draining. I mean that, in my case at least, it exhausts ME, who I am. That it drains not just energy from me, but my sense of self, whatever it is I’ve come over the course of 38 years to think of as my identity, and the integrity of my mind.

In the past when I had nothing else, no other star to guide my ship by, I’ve always relied on the girding strength of my own persona, and felt certain that whatever else was true of me my character was a stalwart force, my mind formidable. These things were constant and would not fail me. But when I became a mother, whole years seemed to pass in which I did not feel I was myself at all, in which I — the “I” I recognized as me, who it is that I understand myself to be — kind of wasn’t there anymore. And not in  the Now I’m A Mom And I’ve Changed And Adapted Myself To Fit This New Reality sort of way. No, I was not a new version of me modified to accommodate a child. I just wasn’t there. *POOF*

Babies and young children compel parents to put their own needs aside, and that’s what I did I guess, but to the absolute extremity. It wasn’t a thought process, a decision I made, to give up myself in order to be a mother. Maybe who I am isn’t, at bottom, all that compatible with motherhood, at least not in its common Selfless Giving Self-Sacrificial manifestation. And if that’s true, perhaps I had to erase myself to be what I needed to be for my daughter in her early years. I’m not quite sure, honestly. Those years are gone now.

The love I feel for my daughter is enormous. I can’t even wrap my head around that kind of love sometimes, it’s so big. And its profundity is what has kept me going even when I’ve been mired in the blackest tar pit of depression — it is the infallible engine inside me that will not quit even when my spirit collapses. But this Fall, when she turned 6 and entered Kindergarten, it truly felt as though I’d emerged from exile. Depression, which had accompanied my self-erasure, lifted. And I saw myself (or, rather, my self) again as I had before, for the first time in years. I felt myself to again be singular Me, not The-Woman-Who-Is-Mother-To-My-Daughter. Maybe it’s horrible to say this, but I felt liberated, glad that my daughter was finally old enough and self-sufficient enough to be gone most of the day, because it meant I could be blissfully alone with myself again, the self I’d misplaced for years.

In the 6 months since, I’ve struggled to not feel intensely protective of my time and energy, to not feel I’m operating at a 6-year-long time deficit and want to hoard every moment I can for myself and only myself because I am owed. I’m trying to find a middle ground, one in which I don’t fall too in love with the return of my independence and singularity, in which I don’t disappear into the mirror reflecting back to me the long lost self I’ve missed so much. It’s hard, though. A few weeks ago I went out and bought something close to a whole new wardrobe, and it was the first time I’d bought any substantive clothing for myself in years. I’d considered my own needs and desires incidental for so long I’d forgotten how to take care of myself, to be good to myself. It’s shocking to realize that now. It makes me incredibly sad to think of it.

Of course I don’t blame my daughter for any of this. She was and is beautiful and perfect, and I very much wanted her, and I would do everything again to have her here with me now. I do wonder though if any of it could have been different for me, or if the part of me that holds the equipment necessary to being a mother is simply broken, damaged, incomplete.

I’d thought for a time about having a second child, about giving my daughter a sibling, something she’s wanted. And I’d like to give that to her, I would. But I’ve realized I can’t. Because as much as she wants a brother or sister, I, in my selfishness, need me more.

. . . . .

Fivestarfriday

This post was picked for Five Star Friday, “The best of what’s being thought and said on the web.” (I’m so totally honored, thank you!)


Like Sweetney on Facebook




  • http://meshealle.blogspot.com Meshealle

    I'm so glad that women are finally feeling the confidence to admit these feelings.
    I can't even imagine having children because of everything I just read. I'm pretty sure that I'm far to selfish and love myself far too much to be a good mom.
    I just lost myself in a relationship for a year and a half because his needs were so much more important to me than mine (which I realize isn't the same as motherhood at all. I promise I'm not comparing.). Now that I'm out of it, I'm remembering how awesome it feels to breathe. I feel like I haven't taken a breath in a year and a half and now suddenly, whatever was sitting on my lungs is gone.
    Thanks for your post. And your honesty.

  • Gabby

    WOW!
    You amaze me with your honesty and bravery. I have three wonderful kids who are my life. I suffer from depression as well and sometimes when I am alone and they are at school I feel SO relaxed and I actually enjoy being ALONE. Just me. Is that bad? I mean, does that make me a bad mother? Dont get me wrong I love spending time with them but there comes a point where my depression is so high that I just wish it was only me and no one else. Of course, I could not live without my children but are these thoughts considered normal or is it the selfishness in me? I am glad to know that I am NOT the only one who feels like this. Thanks for sharing and for helping me understand where this is coming from.
    GRACIAS…..

  • http://www.jenandtonic.ca jenB

    That i why we only have one. You are brave for talking about it and being strong enough to know what is right for you.

  • Lynne

    Delurking to say – this post is exactly why my son is an only child. You wrote exactly what I've tried to explain to friends & family for a long time. Thank you for that.

  • http://www.queenhyperbole.blogspot.com The Queen of Hyperbo

    I am in awe. Seriously. One of the most perfect, honest pieces I've read on this subject, or any subject, for that matter.
    Now about that much-coveted free time . . . how about using some of it to call me, goddammit?

  • Dee

    I've never commented on here before, but just wanted to say that being fully who you are is the most important thing you can do for you and your daughter. As the daughter of an amazing, strong, opinionated, wonderful mother whose whole life and definition of self revolved around me, I would have much rather met and known the mother whose sense of self wasn't 95% based on her role as my mother. She was a fierce graceful woman, but damn I would have loved to seen who she would have been if her sense of self had shown through more then her sense of mother.

  • http://www.ozma.blogs.com ozma

    This is really so interesting. It is not at all like my experience. I think, what that reveals, is that I'm kind of not doing the 'full blown mother' thing. I think my husband is actually doing this more. It is so curious to think about how it can be so different to be a mother if you work than if you don't work and also that there are so many different ways to be a mother.
    What my experience is like is that I work–at least lately–60, 70 hours a week–and I yearn to see my child. All the erasure of me comes from the job. The kid is sort of like all the me I have. Like I am reminded that I am an actual human being who has value over and above whether I am successful at my job by the fact of my child's love and need for me. Even when I didn't work this many hours it was kind of like my kid was a guilt free vacation from work.
    Not like it's never work taking care of my kid. But…I can't explain. It's just my job oppresses me so the work of a child is like a hobby or freedom.
    So of course, I want another kid. I mean, it is weird because, just given my crappy life, I actually never got more sleep than when my daughter was a newborn. I know that sounds bizarre but the breastfeeding cured my insomnia and it was like, for the first time, I actually had something that I was allowed to do besides work or feel guilty for not working.
    I actually have a point here that is about your essay. I feel like what you wrote was beautiful and vulnerable. Your really are a fabulous writer and I actually don't blow smoke about this to people. What you wrote in "Sleep Is For The Weak" was totally brilliant. One of my favorite essays in there or elsewhere. So I feel weird writing this and not just directly responding to what you wrote. It seems like 'but what about ME?' But one of the reasons I'm writing it is kind of to say that I am permitted not to be amazing-with-my-kid-all-day-mom by my job, which is necessary to house us, etc. and so there are actually ways to be a mom that are not total giving in the way it sounds like you were. Maybe these are ways to be a BAD mom! It's actually so far from ideal, I can't even tell you.
    Anyway, what I am trying to say is that you had a unique experience, not just a thing that happens to every mom. That utter selfless giving. I didn't do that. I don't know if I could and you've made me curious to know if I could, although I can never find this out because I have to work too many hours. It's something kind of remarkable, actually. I mean: It's something that you did because of who you are and not everyone does it.
    Also, I'm glad you have you back. You are cool.

  • http://jodifur.com/ jodifur

    what an incredibly brave and honest thing to write. The best thing we can do for our children is to be true to ourselves. And this is what you are doing. Good for you.

  • Katie Kat

    P.S.
    To The Neighbor Girl:
    Your post was so wonderful – a perfect addition to what Tracey said. I will carry your thoughts through this journey. What a gift… thank you!

  • http://www.spellweavers.com ladyeunicorn

    I had been this "Not Me" for 11 years before "Me" came back. I am trying really hard to combine the two and not let one take over the other as happened before.
    I'm happy to know I am not the only one, as I'm sure you are. I never talked about it because it seems so uncaring, but we need to be US as well as Mom. I wish I had an answer for all the new moms so they don't go through the same thing, but it seems we all need to find our own ways, in our own time, back to ourselves.

  • http://www.alimartell.com ali

    this is exactly why i went back to work when my second was 18 months old.
    i LOVE my three kids with every inch of my heart and soul…but i also needed to love ME. i needed time to be away from them, both mentally and physically.
    it took me a long time to admit that going back to work was only a little bit about the money…but more about allowing myself to be what i was before i had kids – ME.

  • http://the-holmes.blogspot.com Holmes

    I'm just glad I'm not the only one who feels this way. One of my most serene moments every day is dropping the kids off at school. There are times when, after having spent the whole day with them or something, I'm ready to go out for the proverbial pack of cigarettes.

  • http://snarking.wordpress.com Snarky Amber

    I'm probably one of the few commenters who doesn't have a child, for the usual reasons. I'm selfish. I need my time alone and I want hours set aside in my day that nobody else gets to have. I want to be defined by my personality and interests and passions and career, not what I am to someone else, whether it's mom or wife.
    Then everyone began telling me, "but that goes away when you have a kid!" and I'd think, "Why would I want that? Why would I want to give myself away? Why would I want to cease to be me the way I am now and to be personally invested in preserving that person, even if it means being selfish? I like me!"
    So, really, I found this post so refreshing because now I know, if I decided to have kids, I could still be ME, even if that would make me feel guilty at times.
    All that said, I hope some part of you realize there's nothing defective about you as a mother. If anything, M will grow up knowing she can define herself, rather than her roles defining her. She will know that being a woman can entail so much more than being a wife and mother, while also knowing that those roles can be fulfilling and empowering, too.

  • http://www.humanbeingblog.wordpress.com Lynn @ humanabeingbl

    My first read of your blog and I chose a brilliant one (linked over from five star fridays).
    I, too, lost myself in motherhood and marriage during the first three years of my daughter's life. Then my marriage fell apart and I was forced to find myself again only to survive. The interesting thing is the self I found I had never met before. And I like her a hell of a lot, enough not to want to off her every day like I wanted to off the old me.
    Your child will find siblings elsewhere. What she needs more than an insta-playmate is a mommy who takes care of herself and puts herself first, because if you aren't whole and well, how can you expect her to be? She needs that role model. Never, never think you are selfish for putting yourself in the picture of your life.
    Lovely, honest post.

  • http://www.miss-britt.com Miss Britt

    I don't think there is anything wrong with being relieved those intensive pre-school years are over and recognizing that you can't – and don't want to – go back to that.

  • http://blogher.com Elisa Camahort Page

    Tracey, wanted to let you know that this post inspired one of your readers to submit it for the BlogHer of the Week. Lisa, Jory and I each related to this post in different ways, and agreed that this is some powerful, honest blogging right here! Congratulations on being this week's BlogHer of the Week:
    http://www.blogher.com/blogher-week-sweetney

  • http://www.megansminute.com More Parents Need To

    More parents need to be this honest about parenthood. There's nothing wrong with the questions you raise and struggling to maintain yourself as you mother your child.
    Great post.

  • http://ordinaryartblog.com kelly

    I love this post.
    I have never been selfless when it comes to my children. In fact, their birth has spurred me to do and be more. I put me first a great deal of the time because that is the only way I will be a good mother.
    I work full-time. I consult. I am writing more than I have ever written. All this because I want them to have that as a model.
    I spent a great deal of time feeling shit guilty for it. I have had other mothers tell me this guilt is deserved, that If I loved my children enough I would give up everything but them. I won't do that.
    I think every mother feels as you do in some way. It just manifest itself differently. I think it would be unreal to expect women to live and breathe and write all love all the time. Even when we want to shake them from our tired legs and just bolt for the door, it does not mean we do not love them.
    Thanks for writing this.

  • http://lettersbackhome.blogspot.com Linda

    Thank you for writing this. I am currently pregnant with my first (and only) child, and this puts into words all the fears I have of becoming a parent. The Husband and I want what's best for our child, but we are too—Selfish? Self-preserving?—to want to expand from "us plus one" to "us with many." We feel that to compromise who *we* are for our child is simply doing it a great disservice.

  • http://agentzoey.blogspot.com agent zoey

    So very real. And thank you for expressing it so eloquently. By putting this out there you have touched many of us who are in, or have been in a depression of similar proportions and made us feel less alone.
    Parenting is exhausting and exhilarating at the same time…I’m going to force my husband to read this so he can see I am not the only one.
    Peace to you.

  • http://www.surrenderdorothyblog.com Rita Arens

    I have one child for a reason, sistah. I, too, have felt like I woke up from a long sleep. Mine happened around the time she turned four, but I think SIFTW kick-started the wake-up process by forcing me to focus on my own self again in time to buck up for the book tour. Once it happened, though, I didn't want to go back. I haven't gone back.

  • http://torristravel.typepad.com b

    I am sixty-seven years old and I have for years berated myself for "not being a better mother". Even though my three children are very successful in life and careers I still felt somewhere along the line I had failed. When I read a blog like yours…honest and soul searching…I realize that I was not a bad mother, I was a normal mother. After all our identity is incredibly important to the human well being. Keeping that identity intact during child rearing years can be almost impossible.

  • Susan

    Can I give you some perspective from someone who has been there, done that? My youngest is now 13. I am not the person I was before I had my kids, and that's okay. I feel I am better, more compassionate, wiser, more confident. Being their mother gave me more than it took, but when I was deep in diapers, sleep deprivation and constant mess and noise I didn't know it would. Mothering small children is the most intense, demanding job on the face of the planet. Yes, you will lose your old self, but only in a sense. The person who comes out the other end of those mothering years (and I'm talking about the time you spend caring for your young children, because you never stop being their mother, and still worry and care about them when they have grown up) is still you, only better. We are meant to grow and change in this life. Parenting is guaranteed to make you do that. You don't have to "erase" yourself to be a good mother. The best advice I received as a new mother, which I did not follow very well, was to make sure I took time for myself. I didn't learn that lesson until late in the game. I would have been a better mom (and a happier person)if I had taken it to heart.

  • Lily

    You put into words all the things I've been feeling but did not know how to properly express. You rock.

  • http://fictionway.com/ Fiction Writer

    My kids are teens now and I still wonder what I've gotten myself into. Now I'm counting down the days until they've gone to college and I feel guilty about it. Thanks for sharing. You're not alone!