Self(ish)

Struggling with depression again as I have been a bit lately, I’ve come to finally accept something about myself: I really don’t possess the selflessness necessary for this being-a-mother thing.

Depression has magnified this lack, I think. Or perhaps I’m just more aware of it, as I’m more myopic and sensitive to all of my shortcomings and failings — as a friend, partner, writer, boss, human being, all of it, all of it. And it’s a form of self-centeredness in itself, the daily accounting of what I lack, how I have fallen short, how I have disappointed. All of this, the countless facets of my deficiency, are thrown into stark relief most when I deal with my daughter because she above all other people on this planet earth requires and requests so much of me on a daily basis. The things she wants, the energy she needs, her questions that require answers, the endless barrage of busywork and errands related to taking care of another, much-less-able human being, is just so, so exhausting. And by “exhausting” I don’t even mean tiring or physically draining. I mean that, in my case at least, it exhausts ME, who I am. That it drains not just energy from me, but my sense of self, whatever it is I’ve come over the course of 38 years to think of as my identity, and the integrity of my mind.

In the past when I had nothing else, no other star to guide my ship by, I’ve always relied on the girding strength of my own persona, and felt certain that whatever else was true of me my character was a stalwart force, my mind formidable. These things were constant and would not fail me. But when I became a mother, whole years seemed to pass in which I did not feel I was myself at all, in which I — the “I” I recognized as me, who it is that I understand myself to be — kind of wasn’t there anymore. And not in  the Now I’m A Mom And I’ve Changed And Adapted Myself To Fit This New Reality sort of way. No, I was not a new version of me modified to accommodate a child. I just wasn’t there. *POOF*

Babies and young children compel parents to put their own needs aside, and that’s what I did I guess, but to the absolute extremity. It wasn’t a thought process, a decision I made, to give up myself in order to be a mother. Maybe who I am isn’t, at bottom, all that compatible with motherhood, at least not in its common Selfless Giving Self-Sacrificial manifestation. And if that’s true, perhaps I had to erase myself to be what I needed to be for my daughter in her early years. I’m not quite sure, honestly. Those years are gone now.

The love I feel for my daughter is enormous. I can’t even wrap my head around that kind of love sometimes, it’s so big. And its profundity is what has kept me going even when I’ve been mired in the blackest tar pit of depression — it is the infallible engine inside me that will not quit even when my spirit collapses. But this Fall, when she turned 6 and entered Kindergarten, it truly felt as though I’d emerged from exile. Depression, which had accompanied my self-erasure, lifted. And I saw myself (or, rather, my self) again as I had before, for the first time in years. I felt myself to again be singular Me, not The-Woman-Who-Is-Mother-To-My-Daughter. Maybe it’s horrible to say this, but I felt liberated, glad that my daughter was finally old enough and self-sufficient enough to be gone most of the day, because it meant I could be blissfully alone with myself again, the self I’d misplaced for years.

In the 6 months since, I’ve struggled to not feel intensely protective of my time and energy, to not feel I’m operating at a 6-year-long time deficit and want to hoard every moment I can for myself and only myself because I am owed. I’m trying to find a middle ground, one in which I don’t fall too in love with the return of my independence and singularity, in which I don’t disappear into the mirror reflecting back to me the long lost self I’ve missed so much. It’s hard, though. A few weeks ago I went out and bought something close to a whole new wardrobe, and it was the first time I’d bought any substantive clothing for myself in years. I’d considered my own needs and desires incidental for so long I’d forgotten how to take care of myself, to be good to myself. It’s shocking to realize that now. It makes me incredibly sad to think of it.

Of course I don’t blame my daughter for any of this. She was and is beautiful and perfect, and I very much wanted her, and I would do everything again to have her here with me now. I do wonder though if any of it could have been different for me, or if the part of me that holds the equipment necessary to being a mother is simply broken, damaged, incomplete.

I’d thought for a time about having a second child, about giving my daughter a sibling, something she’s wanted. And I’d like to give that to her, I would. But I’ve realized I can’t. Because as much as she wants a brother or sister, I, in my selfishness, need me more.

. . . . .

fivestarfriday1 Self(ish)

This post was picked for Five Star Friday, “The best of what’s being thought and said on the web.” (I’m so totally honored, thank you!)

  • http://3bedroombungalow.blogspot.com Kat

    This is such a brave and honest post. Knowing your limits is a good thing. Overstepping what you are capable of handling, not wise.

  • http://www.badladies.blogspot.com Her Bad Mother

    Oof. OOF.
    I don't even know what to say. I know. I KNOW. And yet – I'm not there. Yet. I am so still fully IN THIS. Struggling with it, but still.
    OOF.

  • http://www.ThisBlessedMess.com MrsMessiness

    I do SO admire your ability to write so incredibly honestly – I think a lot of moms will need to read this.
    I hope it helps you feel a bit more free to have written it.

  • http://Crazedmommy.com Shash

    I'm so glad you wrote this. Things like this need to be said and discussed because taking care of yourself is equally important as taking care of others; and more often than not parents, especially mothers, forget that. I appreciate this. Thank you for putting it out there.

  • http://citystreams.wordpress.com citystreams

    I've been struggling with very similar thoughts and ideas. Only I am a teacher, so I get to escape to work and then look forward to the weekends. My 18 month old daughter has brought me SO much joy. But just as you said, I feel myself draining away when I am at home with her for sick days and vacations. I know I'd go insane as a stay at home mom. Yet I sometimes feel that she's missing out because I take her to daycare. The thought of having a second child overwhelms me. I can't imagine how I could stay above water mentally if I had two tiny beings pulling on me all the time. How do people have four and eight and eighteen children? It's beyond me!

  • http://www.miscmum.com Karen (miscmum)

    I geddit. Totally.

  • http://listenupmofos.blogspot.com Florencia

    Dude, there should be a law against getting into other people's heads! You and I had a brief exchange about this and it has kept me thinking about. I 100% understand you and I feel this way often, but of course it's different for me since I can't stay home, I have to work outside the home so I don't get enough time with my daughter as I *think* I wish I could. And the second baby thing is killing me inside. I want my daughter to know the joys of having a sibling, to have the support that I've enjoyed and given to my sister, but I also need to go to law school and how could I possibly do both? Taking care of a baby for the first year means no real sleep or rest, no time to even pee alone (that one I guess goes on for years?) much less study for law school or the Bar. These choices are hard, so hard. I am almost envious of you because you have what it takes to be honest with yourself and your family about what you want and what you know you can or can't do. That right there is the hardest battle and you have won!

  • http://loraleeslooneytunes.com Loralee

    I'm in a puddle of tears here so I hope I can string together a sentence well enough to convey my feelings correctly. I think you touched a really raw nerve. (And I'm pregnant, sick, hormonal as all get out and struggling.)
    My youngest is nine. And while I am certain about this baby and I know I will be happy and it's worth it, I am freaking out at what it means to go back to it all after having years of independence. I feel like I don't have one more OUNCE to give anyone else most days and the baby isn't even HERE yet. Terrified is an understatement.
    And it makes me feel beyond selfish and ungrateful. I feel like that every day-a big, fat whiner. I'm getting another chance at this amazing thing, and look how I am reacting to it.
    The good thing is that I know from experience having the baby here will help, but man…I am so feeling so many things in your writing. This must have been hard to write(It was hard enough for me to just comment on it and I feel like a whiner.)
    Bravo.

  • http://www.shelikespurple.com She Likes Purple

    You are so brave and incredible. You know I just had a kid, and this really gripped me. It's something I've already struggled with, not even one month under my belt.

  • http://www.canedlaffs.com Joie at Canned Laugh

    The world would be a happier better place if more people had the ability to be this honest with themselves. Also? Shhhhh… no one will think any less of you if you take less on for your daughter's sake. I myself was shocked to discover that my daughter is not growing up to be an ax murderess just because I said no to "activities" and gasp! stopped agreeing to so-called volunteer opportunities.

  • http://bradstein.blogspot.com Papa Bradstein

    It's a struggle we all face as parents, and all of us find our own balance.
    I was intrigued by this bit:
    "Babies and young children compel parents to put their own needs aside, and that's what I did I guess, but to the absolute extremity. It wasn't a thought process, a decision I made, to give up myself in order to be a mother."
    Perhaps it's just the birds who I flock with, but I don't know any parents who felt they had a choice or gave it any thought. Since having 3B, I've thought it was one of those profound inexorable processes of becoming a parent.
    I'm not trying to say trying to say that this shift isn't important, but that I hope you realize that you're in good company. Every parent I know has given themselves over to their child in the most extreme way possible for them. There are lots of us out here who understand what you're talking about–as best we can through the web and all that.
    As for your derision of your selfishness…our kids want us to be selfish. They want us to be happy. When cabin pressure unexpectedly drops, they want us to put on our own mask before helping them with theirs. They want us to be happy, just as we want them to be happy. May the circle be unbroken.
    As you find your balance, I think you'll find plenty of parents who are stumbling along the same path you are. You're not alone.

  • kristen

    you are so not alone!
    one of my favorite quotes (actually the title of a random magazine article from 10 years ago about the same struggle)and i think it almost every day: "I love being a mother, I hate parenting"
    props for owning it though! if you do recognize it you empower yourself to be a better parent because you know your biggest weakness.

  • CharmCity

    I am not a mother. The reason is because I knew I was too selfish to be a mother, and I had this horrible feeling inside of me that I would come to resent any child I had for making me sacrifice too much of myself. Many women judge me for being able to say such things. I'm glad I am not the only one who can say something like this. You are very brave, and very entitled to these feelings.

  • http://heels.crumpled.com/ heels

    I don't see that as broken at all. In fact, I think it's incredibly healthy to recognize your needs and your limits and to proceed accordingly, rather than trying to force yourself into something that doesn't seem right (having a second child). I'm impressed with your introspective abilities. Also, a sibling is not nearly as important than your daughter being able to see you being happier with yourself and feeling able to be more completely yourself.

  • http://www.westwardbound.wordpress.com Must Be Motherhood

    I'm only 2.5 years and two kids into this thing and I'm already worried I won't recognize the ME that emerges when they're off to school. I'm already raising my fist in protest "WHAT ABOUT ME?!" from under the weight of scraping poop off of little butts and carrying babies around on my chest.
    There are many, many days when I think about how close I came to trusting my self-preservation instincts and decided against the second. (Tho, Lawd, how I love him.)
    Thanks for opening the conversation up on this one.

  • http://www.momofali.com Momo Fali

    These are the things no one tells you before you become a parent…that you will lose a lot of yourself, if not all, after you have children. You hear about the poop, and the spit-up, and the sleepless nights, but no one tells you that you won't buy new shoes for yourself until the ones you own are glaringly out of style, and even then you'll think, "Meh. These are fine."

  • http://pacingthepanicroom.blogspot.com Ryan

    I think anytime a person can look at themselves and figure out what's really going on inside of them, and then in turn have the courage to actually say it out loud and make smart decisions based off that analysis, that person is a hero not only to themselves, but to the people around them.

  • http://www.drowninginkids.com jess

    So very well said. I have felt this and recognized it in myself for a few years. Now that i have all four in school the fog of depression is lifting, for me.
    xo

  • http://www.motherbumper.com/ katie ~ motherbumper

    The internal struggle of sorting out this feeling of being selfish for not embracing the selfless, is something I'm working through on my own these days (hell, make that years). It's comforting to know others feel this way because it really is a lonely struggle. Finding a safe spot to talk about it without feeling fully naked after sharing is the hard part (though not impossible.)

  • Joy

    Has to be said, Trace. Most of us feel this to some degree or another. Well done.

  • http://onein36million.wordpress.com Melanie

    Hi,
    I'm a single and sole parent to a three year old, and I fight depression continually. I have for years. What you wrote sounds remarkably familiar, scarily so, as it's not where I am now but where I could see myself easily getting.
    I don't know if you would like suggestions. If you don't, please disregard this, it's just meant to help not to hurt or place any expectations (of course! You don't know me, I don't know you).
    Two actions keep me treading water, keep me knowing me.
    I take care, every day, to make note of things that made me happy — and they cannot all be my son, and they cannot all be "I made so-and-so happy by doing X". Often I'll share these on my blog. I look for special moments that I should treasure, that would otherwise be lost in the swarm of angry, dark thoughts. This helps to identify the 'me' in my life, as these are things that made ME happy.
    The other thing that I do is I take part in a discussion group for mothers. It's aimed at moms like me, who feel they've lost themselves and need to reclaim their identity beyond working, mothering, being a partner. We work through a book called the Mother's Guide to Self-Renewal, discussing our thoughts on the chapters, and branching off from there. Sometimes the 'lessons learned' have little to do with the chapters themselves.
    Okay … I've written a hugelong post … and I'm just going to hit 'post' before I decide to can it.
    I hope things improve for you. It's not selfish to wish to have a self.

  • http://www.breedemandweep.com Jenn

    We
    hear
    you
    loud
    and
    clear.
    Do
    not
    be
    shy.
    This
    is
    truth.
    xo

  • http://domesticextraordinaire.blogspot.com Domestic Extraordina

    I love my girls-I really do. I think that my *problem* for so long was that I didn't have my own identity. I didn't know *who* I was. I went from being a kid to having a kid in 2.3 seconds flat-while as much as I have loved being a mother to my kids and wouldn't change a thing, I really love who I have become. This last year or so I have really found who I am. I enjoy my own company-I enjoy doing things for myself and while I do enjoy doing things for my girls I realized that for my sanity and the happiness of the household I need to be myself and not try to fit myself into some sort of cookie cutter *mom* shape that I have tried to shove myself into for far too long (Giggles is over 14 now) Not that I think you are shoving yourself into the *mom* mold-I admire you-your frankness, your honesty. I totally pink puffy heart you..*smooches*
    thanks for writing this and letting me ramble a bit.

  • http://www.theanviltree.com Sarah Lena

    Oh, honey, me too. Me too, and AMEN, and yes, sister and all that jazz.
    Mine is but a mere toddler, but already I long for who I once was. And I don't long for there to be a lack of HIM, but just a HIM + ME equation that offers some sort of balance. My husband does not understand this, and when I leave work early he doesn't understand why I don't IMMEDIATELY go pick up the child, why sometimes I have to go stroll the aisles of Target, to buy nothing in particular but just to shop for my hypothetical ME. Clothes ME would've wanted. The bedroom ME would've decorated. Those scarce half hours between careerME and momME are the sanity savers I force myself to take.
    I think you're pretty rockin', if that helps.

  • veronica

    I'm not a mom, but it doesn't surprise me that others have said you're not alone.
    I've made the choice to not have kids in part for that very fear (among others).
    I think it's amazing that people do learn how to manage it, get thru it, and as you said…would still do it over because of the love you feel for her. That in itself shows me that none of you are truly selfish.
    Even to this day I have to remind my mother (of 5 – the youngest being 34) that it's ok to say no to us and put herself or my step-dad before us….I'd say she's earned that by now :)

  • http://www.dutchblitz.net/ Angella

    I'm proud of you for writing this, Tracey. So many women need to feel like they are not alone.
    I do not struggle with depression, but I do know that as my kids are getting older and more independent, I (and my husband) are loving the freedom that comes with that.
    I hear you on this. Totally.

  • http://www.wishwaithopepray.com Emily

    I'm pregnant with my first child and I do worry about this. Its taken me a long time to get to a point where I generally like who I am. What will happen to that person after the baby arrives? Can I hold onto her – should I try? Thanks for such a thought provoking honest piece of writing.

  • http://mamabub.blogspot.com Mama Bub

    Oh my, you're in my head. While I answer most people with "someday" when they ask when we'll have another baby, in my head I'm saying "never." I love and adore my son and certainly wouldn't take bake one minute of the last 21 months. But, he's enough.

  • http://pandorican.wordpress.com Pando

    As I'm sure you can see by all of your comments you are not the only one in this particular boat.
    I have written things that are almost word for word what you just said. I love my kid(s) and wouldn't give them up for the world, but they sucked the me out of me. Now, with my youngest gone in school, I finally have time to just BE. To try and re-find my creativity, my identity, mySELF.
    Having said that, I desperately want her to have a sibling, someone to be there with her, for her, when I am gone, so I am preparing to put myself aside yet again to do this for her. I hope I make it through.
    And I applaud you for your honestly about your choice not to do it again.

  • http://www.moonflykids.com moon_fly

    Yes, and YES.
    Thank you for making me feel *not alone*. Sometimes the seething resentment I feel as a mother is more than I can handle, and I hate myself for it. But it is there and needs to be addressed. I tackle it in small doses.
    And, OMG, I still have about 3 more years till Kindy. ::weeps::

  • http://www.sweetsalty.com sweetsalty kate

    1) Know thyself.
    2) Drink thy beer.
    xo

  • http://cravingsilence.blogspot.com Shania

    August 28, 2009. That's the day Silas starts kindergarten. And I'm counting them down.

  • Angela

    I love you, Tracey. This was really brave. When I was in the depths of it, when R was little, and realizing that I just.could.not. do it again, there was nothing like this anywhere that I could find. And I felt so lonely and alienated and … alien. Like something was wrong with me that wasn't wrong with other people and I better not ever let on. I couldn't tell my own mom, I didn't have any friends who'd had babies at all, much less been through this kind of shit, and so I just said horrible things to myself about how fucked up and mean and atrocious I was.
    Later, it was meeting other mamas, ESPECIALLY you, and hearing and speaking these truths, that made me feel like a human being again. Like it was possible that I actually was a good person and that I could be a good mom to my daughter even though all of these things were true, that I don't have any more to give and that actually sometimes I don't really have what I give already.
    I'm glad you wrote this. I'm glad you hit post. I'm really fucking glad I know you.

  • baltimoregal

    Beautiful and perfect.

  • bouncy

    I am glad you said something. I thought I was alone with these thoughts.

  • http://kdiddy.org kdiddy

    I love you, lady

  • http://noteverstill.blogspot.com noteverstill

    There is *nothing* wrong with coming to that conclusion, and there is *lots* right and brave in saying out loud, especially so publicly – posts like this empower women facing tough decisions, however they work them out.

  • http://wherewiller.wordpress.com Emma

    This is one of the best things I've ever read by you, in my little humble opinion – not that you aren't normally honest in anything I've read that you've written – but this one really hits close to home and just strikes me as brutally amazingly honest.
    I had NO IDEA how selfless it meant to be a parent to small kids. No idea. Totally blindsided by it. Still dealing with the resentment of having to schedule a pee break. Probably would have thought long and hard about having number 2 if he hadn't suddenly accidentally appeared! I have to be at work so I have my me-time. As great as my kids can be, I really look forward to nurturing more and more independence in them.
    Nice work, lady.

  • http://www.mamalogues.com Dana

    Don't feel less than; feel more than because of your honesty. Some are too afraid to be as forthcoming.

  • http://fairlyoddmother.blogspot.com Fairly Odd Mother

    I remember in 11th grade Philosophy class, I had to read a book called "Looking out for #1"—totally ridiculous book but it also made a lot of sense to me—I've always thought of myself as essentially "alone" and have a sort of hyper-awareness of my needs. And, even though my kids don't go anywhere when most other kids hop on a bus for school, that feeling of being "me", even if it is muted a bit right now, still exists inside.

  • http://daisybones.com daisybones

    This is EXACTLY why I don't want another child, although biologically a soft wooshy bit inside me does. I just can't give any more. I feel you so completely, here in toddlerhood and looking forward to seeing more independence in the girl. I'm thrilled you've articulated this and shared it and seeing the comments here is sort of validating for me too by proxy. I hope it bolsters you.

  • http://www.survivalfloat.blogspot.com/ PrestoKareno

    I never realized that I felt the same way until I read your post.

  • http://www.2passthetorch.com Kelly @ Pass the Tor

    What a beautiful post. Raw and honest. This is what's so great about blogging – you give us the permission to feel with honesty what we feel about motherhood, when you share your own trials.
    One comment about the second child thing… It's a huge decision, and only you can make it. I don't know you at all, but I do know that for me, having a second child made motherhood easier (as an aside, I am personally an only child.)
    When they have each other, it's almost like they need me less, and there's a built in social mechanism. They learn so much from each other. (They're only 2 years apart, though, so that contributes.)
    Something to think about…for whatever it's worth..

  • The neighbor girl

    I too felt this way. I chalked it up to being young, alone, misunderstood and a bit confused as to what a mother really was. I grew up as a single child virtually alone in the country with no other mothers with which to compare. I though it must be abnormal, but didn't give it too much more thought. Eventually the me that was, sort of disappeared. I had post-partum depression and just assumed that it was some lingering piece. I did my best to raise my little person and provide everything that she needed, although I always felt as if I still wasn't giving quite enough. I wondered where I had gone and thought that I had totally lost myself. I rejoiced when she could do overnight trips at grandma's, when she was old enough to play in the back yard alone..when I could leave her with food and a television and not worry that she'd choke to death on a hot dog. Now that she's 12, it's a very odd thing. She has her own routine, her own way of doing things and doesn't need me so much, but in everything she does I see where my self went. What I learned was that I had placed so much of myself in her that it seemed lost. As I watch her move gracefully into young adulthood I realize that I didn't just lose myself, I gave myself to her and somewhere inside her I am still there, with her; and I'm grateful. I've since spent my time building a new me to meet my next life phase and it's invigorating. The best part is that when you are all gone, when your child is filled up with you and begins to move along on their own path, you are left with a blank canvas to paint whatever color you choose.

  • http://redstapler23.blogspot.com Suebob

    The truth is important, and I am glad you said it and that you did it in such a thoughtful, articulate way.
    I understand because I chose not to have kids because I thought I would have the same type of issues. I need a LOT of alone time – at least 4-5 hours a day. Alone. By myself. All by myself, to be able feel like all is right in my world.

  • http://www.missesmisadventures.blogspot.com Miss E

    I just came upon your site today and wow — what. an. amazing. post. You are so honest and real – it's inspiring. I've been married for 3.5 years and at that point where we are discussing the kid situation. While I know deep down I want them, I'm scared to death of losing myself. I'm so glad to read your words and know that I'm not alone.
    Thank you.

  • http://mrs.flinger.us Mrs. Flinger

    YESSSS!!! That’s SO ExACTLY how I feel. And I have two. And of course I love them both and I wouldn’t trade them for the world (or a PhD which was what I quit when I had my first). But honestly? I’m good with not having more. I’m ready for me to shine.
    Your time to shine is now. As a mom, as a person, as a friend, as you. XOXO

  • marie

    Thanks for saying this again. At one time (horrifying as it might sound) I equated the experience of becoming a mother to having some kind of terrible trauma to my body, and my mind, like maybe cancer or amputation, requiring a drastic adjustment in self-perception and learning to walk again.
    I have some childless women friends who are single and almost 40, and they ask me what I think of their plans to have a child on their own– I think I outright said to one: "It's like having a leg cut off. Don't do it unless you have a LOT of help."
    I also know, that because I have my son, I can't lose my shit and go crazy. I don't have that luxury anymore.
    There is no way I would ever have another baby, and am counting on my sister to provide some type of relative for my kid.
    I am glad you have started feeling like yourself again- I think I have a year to go.. and that whole new wardrobe thing, that sounds divine- congratulations on that. And see you at the Blog-her, I have no excuse not to be there.

  • Katie Kat

    Man Tracey, if I could reach through the computer and hug you, I would. What you wrote in this post is what lurks in the back of my brain every day… it's the dirty little secret – the fear – the sometimes heart wrenching disappointment in myself that threatens to drag me back into my own hell of depression.
    I could NOT have put it any more clearly or profoundly. And after reading some of the comments here, I feel like I'm not the only one. I sometimes say, being my little girl's "MOM" is the greatest, most amazing, wonderful thing in my life, but being a parent? THAT SUCKS.
    I do miss "me" and all the things I could/should (?) be doing or experiencing or whatever. And at the same time the love I feel for my daughter fills my innermost self with joy and pride. When she calls me "Mommy," sometimes I can't believe she's talking about me! I mean, I was NEVER EVER EVER EVER EVER going to even get married, let alone have a *gasp* child! Hearing her call me mommy reminds me that I have done what I never thought I would even attempt. It's proof that I can conquer what seems insurmountable.
    Thanks for your honesty and for helping us all see that there is a light at the end of the tunnel!

  • http://www.becomingsomething.com Natasha

    I could have written nearly this entire post myself. The depression, the selfish need, etc. My problem, on top of that, is that I have four kids and by the time Lulu is in school full time, I will have done this for 12 years. Twelve years of NOISENOISENOISE and MESS. Twelve years of profound sleep deprivation. No family to help. Very busy husband. Add a stupid dog into the mix that I fantasize about murdering each day. And I started all this so young that I haven't had a chance to go to university and develop my artistic talents to the degree I COULD.
    I would like more kids, ideally. But I'm too selfish, too. I can't even give to my husband as much as he gives to me. Because my crappy childhood left me with an intense, endless feeling of deprivation.
    Sigh.